Aging Breast Implants

Breast implants aren’t lifetime devices. Dr. James F. Boynton, our board-certified plastic surgeon in Houston, has been performing revision breast augmentation since 2003. He explains what happens as implants age and why anyone with implants, particularly implants that are older than 10 years, should get checked by a board-certified plastic surgeon.

Aging breast implants is an important topic I believe we should talk about. I’ve been a board-certified plastic surgeon for over 22 years, and I have been doing breast augmentation surgery, and more specifically revision breast augmentation, since 2003. Many women had breast augmentation in their 20s and got busy with life and forgot about them, and now in their 50s they have not been “checked” by a plastic surgeon since the surgery was done. Each month I get a number of calls, usually after a patient similar to the ones described above gets a mammogram or ultrasound and there is some change to her breast in terms of shape, how it feels (i.e., discomfort), or just general anxiety because the radiologist found an “abnormality” with the aging implant. The other scenario that is quite common, and certainly anxiety-provoking, is someone with aging saline breast implants. Saline implants were designed to last about 10 years, and many patients far exceed that “recommended shelf life.” The caveat is that aging saline implants can just “deflate” without warning, and a “flat tire” effect shows up instantly, prompting a call I usually get.

The breast implant was invented in Houston, Texas, in the early 1960s. I had the fortunate pleasure of training with Dr. Thomas Biggs, who was involved in the first breast augmentation at St. Joseph in Houston, which is the institution where the breast implant was invented. They had a strong tradition and history of excellence in breast augmentation and revision breast augmentation starting from the very beginning, so this area of expertise has always been a passion for me in my aesthetic plastic surgery practice.

Silicone gel breast implants have been used in some form or capacity since the early ’60s. In the early ’90s, and in 1994 specifically, there was a moratorium placed on silicone gel implants until 2006. They were still used on a trial basis during the 14-year moratorium. Many plastic surgeons felt that they were still safe for use, and they continued to be used in clinical trials during that time. Most of the “bad press” in the media about breast implants turned out not to be scientifically accurate, and it created a lot of anxiety about silicone gel breast implants. Many plastic surgeons switched predominantly to saline breast implants during that time period. After 2006, most patients elect to choose silicone gel breast implants. However, there are still some who prefer saline breast implants.

We are now, essentially, on generation-five silicone gel breast implants, and there are FDA-approved makers of silicone gel breast implants: Sientra®, Motiva®, Mentor®, and Allergan®. I typically prefer Mentor and Motiva, for different reasons, in different types of anatomy and different patients. Motiva implants are typically my choice when the implant will be placed subfascially or subglandularly (on top of the muscle). For implants placed under the muscle, Mentor BOOST implants are my favorite; they tend to have less rippling and often provide a very natural look and feel.
I think it’s important for patients who have aging breast implants, which I would define as more than 10 years old, and definitely if they are over 20 years old, to know this. Sometimes I get patients a few times a month with 30-year-old implants that have not been seen since they were placed. We know just from history that any implant that’s more than 10 years old, and definitely more than 20 years old, will often become contracted. They essentially wear out, and when they do, they can become misshapen and harden, and they can develop something known as capsular contracture, which can become more advanced. The implants can also rupture.

“Rupture” is a loaded term that scares a lot of patients, and I prefer to use the term “wear out.” Breast implants are not living tissue, and they wear out over time. When breast implants are originally placed, the body forms a biological capsule (a scar tissue envelope, if you want to think of it that way) around the implant. So even when they do rupture, more than 90% of the time it’s called an intracapsular rupture, where the implant material is still contained within that scar tissue envelope. Sometimes there can be an extracapsular rupture in really advanced cases, but those cases are rare and almost exclusively seen in patients who have completely ignored their implants for many decades. These are some of the important reasons that patients with aging implants, even saline implants, need to get checked out.

Many patients have this “one and done” philosophy: they forget about their implants and move on with life. Life gets busy, they have their mammograms, and sometimes they’ll see a change on a mammogram, at which point they come to see me. Many times the original plastic surgeon has retired, or maybe they’ve moved to another state. There are a number of reasons, and people just move on with their lives. Maybe they had breast implants placed after having children, and then, later in life, in their 50s or 60s, they’ve forgotten about them. I think ultrasound technology has really advanced. It’s a really good surveillance tool to check the integrity of an implant, and it’s a very easy, simple procedure that’s not as uncomfortable as a mammogram. My recommendation for any patient who has implants more than 10 years old is that they should see a board-certified plastic surgeon (ideally one experienced in revision breast augmentation), which is something I have been passionate about for more than 20 years.

It’s also worth mentioning textured implants. Macrotexturing (big texture) has now been taken off the market. This was a technique designed many years ago, in the ’80s and ’90s, perhaps to help limit capsular contracture and implant migration. A small number of these patients developed ALCL (anaplastic large cell lymphoma), which usually develops from a sudden fluid collection many years after having breast implants, another reason to get checked out. Most patients don’t know whether they had textured implants from that time period, but this is another reason it’s important to get “checked out” by a board-certified plastic surgeon.
Patients can then see what their options are. Most of the time, the anatomy has changed and the implants have essentially worn out; they’re old. We can expect to remove the old implant material and the old capsule, or a portion of it, and replace them with new, updated implants that have more cross-linking and cohesivity, usually with a better shape and position. The newer implants also last longer. Sometimes we do pocket changes, meaning if the implants were on top of the muscle, they may go below the muscle or under the fascia. Alternatively, if they’re under the fascia, they may go on top of the muscle. Some of the newer implants allow for better integration with just the breast tissue alone, without having to be under the muscle, which in times past often had to be the case.

Sometimes we’re adding breast lifts (breast augmentation with lift) at the same time. Sometimes it’s done in a staged fashion, and these are all things a board-certified plastic surgeon can discuss with you. The longer we wait, the worse the problem can get, or the implants can become more severely ruptured. Sometimes, early on, an ultrasound may show a suspected rupture while the capsule is still not diseased or thickened, and it doesn’t have to be removed. In those cases, the surgery is less comprehensive than in more advanced, 30-year cases, where there is more going on.

So, all the more reason not to create alarm or anxiety, but I do think there’s a consensus with the American Society of Plastic Surgeons that patients who have had implants for longer than 10 years, and who haven’t seen their plastic surgeon, should go see one, especially if it’s been more than 15 or 20 years. They should definitely make an appointment, come in, and let their surgeon do some measurements, examine them, and check the integrity of the implant. 

This blog was written by Dr. James F. Boynton, a board-certified plastic surgeon. 
If you have questions about breast implants and breast augmentation surgery, or if you would like to schedule a consultation with Dr. Boynton, please contact us today.